where have all the microtones gone?


Back to mother land, the genius musician Phạm Duy has published a new album named – Ngày trở về – The return day. Participated in performance are hit divas of contemporary Vietnamese music: Mỹ Linh and Thanh Lam. There’ve been other artists among the performing group (Đức Tuấn, Quang Dũng, Hồng Hạnh, Hồ Quỳnh Hương…), but I just mention some main figures here. The others are far from being called (hit) singer (if not to say that they even ruin the songs they perform). (In Vietnamese song music, there’s quite a distinction between song composer and song performer, they are rarely the same person.)

Tình ca - Thái Thanh - 1969 ►
Tình ca - Thái Thanh ►
Tình ca - Mỹ Linh ►
Tình ca - Lệ Mai ►

There have been some opinions on the album. No explicit criticism from officials, and in private places, people mention about the album with some joy & eagerness. The composer himself showed some surprising and satisfied attitude toward the singers. But it should be noticed that the great Phạm Duy is always a good businessman (his market-place style makes some people not to love him sometimes). (Last 2005 end, in a ‘symbolic act’, the Sơn Ca communication company had bought the first 10 notes – and only 10 notes: tôi yêu tiếng nước tôi, từ khi mới ra đời – of his song, Tình ca, to use in their product at a price of 100 million VND. Detail is here.)

Back to the music, Tình ca (Love song) may not be among the musician’s most glamorous songs. But from a social point of view, the song is very special in a way that it is statement for Vietnamese identité nationale (national identity). Generations of Vietnameses have grown up with its tune and verse in their soul. The song is quite simple: a pure Vietnamese pentatonic scale, balanced and firm arrangement, and little use of microtone notes, compared to many of his other songs which may get really delicate and complicated, and which require the performer not only of skillful vocal techniques but also deep understanding on Vietnamese traditional tunes.

As pointed out in my previous posts (Microtones and Eastern music part 1, part 2, part 3), the microtonal music is special in a way that it can not be scripted by conventional (Western) musical notation. The vibration, duration and movement in notes & tunes are so subtle and delicate that it would take whole life for one to live in a culture to feel and understand them. Each culture has its own microtones as its fingerprints that characterize it with others. Let “compare” some presentations of this same piece of music, first by Thái Thanh, then by a non-professional singer Lệ Mai, and this final record of Mỹ Linh.

Mỹ Linh outperforms others in term of studio techniques. With excellent harmonization done by Đức Trí, the piece sounds really impressive. While Lệ Mai sang emotionally with a single guitar accompaniment, and Thái Thanh ‘s extreme voice was recorded some 40 years ago on LP 78 vinyl disks. But for one who has enjoyed the old pieces would say: *TOO BAD* upon listening to the new one. Mỹ Linh seems to mimic, with her excellent vocal techniques, some microtonal melody sections that she does not seem to feel and understand. I myself stress heavily on the microtonal notes, which best describe the music identities. There’s some part in the song that tune comes really close to natural speech with all notes of almost the same pitch, where music comes return to resemble mother tongue in a beautiful and splendid contour. Mỹ Linh has missed all those subtleties out of her presentation.

Where have all the microtones gone?

We won’t talk about preserving traditional music here; things move and have to move. The thing is a way of perceiving and conceiving, an ear of music, when even a most recognized singer can’t feel and express, then a whole school of music has extincted and disappeared to nowadays young Vietnameses.

phạm duy, ngày trở về

Well, eventually, this big music show… Ngày trở về – The return day, an event I’ve been waiting for years, many years! Putting aside all the debates over the decades, all political and historical odds and ends, then what rest are these splendid melodies, these profound and delicate vibrations. But feel like something has nearly gone forever, it’s late to find a generation who could understand and love their native, natural tunes, their musical heritage!

Ngày trở về - Thái Thanh ►
Ngày trở về - Ánh Tuyết ►
Ngày trở về - Hoàng Oanh ►

Ngày trở về, anh bước lê trên quãng đường đê đến bên lũy tre. Nắng vàng hoe, vườn rau trước hè cười đón người về. Mẹ lần mò, ra trước ao, nắm áo người xưa ngỡ trong giấc mơ. Tiếc rằng ta đôi mắt đã loà vì quá đợi chờ…

Ngày trở về, những đoá hoa, thấm thoát mười năm nhớ anh vắng xa. Có nhiều khi đời hoa chóng già vì thiếu mặn mà. Đàn trẻ đùa bên lũ trâu, tiếng hát bình minh thoáng trên bãi dâu. Gió về đâu, còn thương tiếc người giọng hát rầu rầu…

phạm duy’s music

These days, I’m very interested in Pham Duy’s music and gather an almost – completed collection of his songs. Besides the outstanding melodies, rhythms, harmonies and forms, I’ve tried to explore the root of all evils (all good and bad), here the microtones, something so crucial and inseparable to our nature. Sometimes, I wonder if these things had been extinct and still conceivable in our current chaotic cultural environment.

Below are some midi files to get an idea on the music. Synthesizers (computer MIDI…) can now partly convey the microtones thanks to new improvements. You can hear to get an idea on his music. For mp3s, try out online music sites such as: http://www.dactrung.net. Tôi yêu tiếng nước tôi, từ khi mới ra đời, người ơi…, the musician should be acknowledged as the most brilliant figure in Vietnamese music.